If you need waterproof protection and the lowest cost, choose an LDPE poly mailer. If you want a natural paper feel and packaging you can call 100% compostable, choose a kraft paper mailer. That is the short answer. Poly mailers are waterproof, tear-resistant, and light to ship, which makes them the workhorse for clothing and soft goods. Kraft paper mailers are recyclable and 100% compostable, and they give parcels a warm, premium paper look — but single-layer kraft paper is not waterproof, so it suits dry goods and indoor delivery routes. This article compares the two side by side, so you can pick the one that fits your product, your brand, and your customers. Prices are worked out per order for both, so send your quantity and size for a quote.
At a Glance
| Feature | Poly mailer (LDPE) | Kraft paper mailer |
| Material | LDPE plastic | Kraft paper |
| Waterproof | Yes — keeps rain and splashes out | No — single-layer kraft paper is not waterproof |
| Tear resistance | Very good | Good, but paper tears more easily than plastic |
| Recyclable | Yes — described as recyclable | Yes — recyclable |
| Compostable | No | Yes — 100% compostable (kraft paper only) |
| Look and feel | Smooth plastic, full-colour print | Warm natural paper look |
| Best for | Clothing, soft goods, wet-weather shipping | Dry goods, premium unboxing, eco-focused brands |
| Minimum order | 100 / 1,000 / 5,000 pcs by tier | Confirm by quote |
| Lead time | 10–15 days | Confirm by quote |
When to Choose a Poly Mailer
Choose the poly mailer when protection comes first:
- Your parcels travel in rain. The LDPE bag is waterproof and keeps the contents dry.
- You ship soft goods. Clothing, socks, and textiles fit well and the bag is light to ship.
- You want full-colour print. Gravure prints 1–7 colours, digital printing has no colour limit, and screen printing covers 1–2 colours.
- You want a low starting order. Stock sizes with a single-colour logo start at 100 pieces.
The poly mailer is the default choice for most clothing brands — it is the workhorse.
When to Choose a Kraft Paper Mailer
Choose the kraft paper mailer when the paper feel and the eco message matter most:
- Your brand leads with sustainability. The kraft bag is recyclable and 100% compostable.
- You want a premium unboxing. Natural brown paper with a printed logo feels warm and considered.
- Your goods stay dry. Kraft paper suits dry goods and delivery routes where rain is not a risk.
- You print a simple logo. Kraft paper takes printed logos well; check a sample first for light colours on dark paper.
One caution: do not call a kraft mailer waterproof. Single-layer kraft paper is not waterproof, and a soaked parcel will show it.
Can You Use Both?
Yes — many brands do. A common split is poly mailers for standard online orders and kraft paper mailers for a premium line or gift orders. The two bags can share the same logo and brand colours, so the customer still recognises your brand either way. If you go this route, keep the eco wording separate: compostable for the kraft paper line, recyclable for the plastic line.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is cheaper, a kraft paper mailer or a poly mailer?
Prices are worked out per order for both, so there is no fixed answer. Send your quantity, size, and design for a quote on each.
Is a kraft paper mailer waterproof?
No. Single-layer kraft paper is not waterproof. If your parcels face rain, choose the LDPE poly mailer.
Is a poly mailer recyclable?
Poly mailers are described as recyclable only. The 100% compostable claim applies to kraft paper products alone.
Is a kraft paper mailer compostable?
Yes. Magicalpack kraft paper bags are 100% compostable. This applies to kraft paper products only.
Can I print my logo on both?
Yes. Both take custom logo printing. Kraft paper shows print differently from plastic, so check a sample first.